Episode 61 – Behavior in the Fossil Record

Listen to Episode 61 on PodBean, iTunes, YouTube or that other podcast player you like!

Ancient animals didn’t just stand around. They moved, interacted, hunted, reproduced, and did all the things animals do. It’s easy to image all of that information is lost to time, but there are all sorts of ways paleontologists can find those clues. In this episode, we’re exploring the tools, techniques, and amazing fossil finds that help us understand Behavior in the Fossil Record.

In the news
The first known Denisovan jaw!
Ambopteryx longibrachium, a new “bat-winged” dinosaur from China.
Ice Age animals from the bottom of a flooded cave in Mexico.
Computer models, a baby ostrich, and a robot dinosaur reveal a potential origin to flapping in winged dinosaurs.

Studying Behavior

The study of behavior is known as ethology, and it’s just as important in understanding the lives of animals as they study of their bones and bodies. Georges Cuvier was one of the first to suggest that we could study behavior in the fossil record.

He suggested that we could use animals’ morphology to understand their behavior, since “form follows function.” He’s not wrong, but it’s also not that simple. Animal behaviors can be as varied as the diets of brown bears or as unexpected as the habits of fruit-eating crocodilians. So getting behavioral information out of fossils is tricky … but not impossible.

Climbing goats in a tree
You wouldn’t think form the skeletons of goats that they could expertly climb trees! Image by François Bianco form Flickr.

Here are a few of the main categories of evidence we use to interpret fossil behavior.

The skeleton

There are some physical features that act as pretty reliable indicators of behavior. Limb proportions and dental features can give hints about how an animal moved and what it ate, while stress fractures and muscle scarring on bones can tell you how an animal was using its body and what pressures it encountered.

But you have to be careful. New adaptations don’t often arise until after a behavior has started. Evidence has shown, for example, that ancient elephants began eating grass millions of years before they finally evolved the dental features for their new diet.

Modern Analogues

Sometimes, the best way to understand the behavior of extinct species is to compare them to living species. An ancient animal with wings is probably behaving similarly to modern winged animals. Animals are also likely to share a lot with their living relatives, so ancient turtles were probably behaving like modern turtles.

But some ancient animals like dinosaurs aren’t very similar to living animals, so we have to try a few different approaches. If you’re trying to understand how a giant dinosaur moved, for example, you might compare it to modern large animals like elephants.

And when paleontologists want to interpret dinosaur behavior or physiology, they can use a technique called phylogenetic bracketing. This involves looking at their closest and next-closest relatives to find features they share. The logic here is that if birds (living dinosaurs) and crocodilians (dinosaurs’ closest living cousins) share a heritable feature (say, their respiratory system or their instinctual habits), it’s likely their last common ancestor had that feature, too. And that ancestor also gave rise to all other dinosaurs, so perhaps they inherited the same traits.

Crocodile_Mom.jpg
A prime example of what phylogenetic bracketing can teach us about dinosaur behavior is the fact that both crocodilians and birds show dedicated parental care. This is unusual among other reptiles so it suggests parental care is common among archosaurs and therefore likely among dinosaurs. Left: mother crocodile (most likely Crocodylus siamensis) with a baby on her back by Njitesh17 from Wikimedia Commons. Right: a Pacific Black Duck mother followed by her ducklings by Paula M Wolter from Wikimedia Commons.

It’s not a perfect approach. Sometimes traits can be lost in certain parts of the family tree, and other times similar traits can appear multiple times through convergent evolution. But in concert with other approaches, phylogenetic bracketing can be very useful.

Computer Models

With information from fossil and modern animals, scientists can digitize the information to simulate the physical limitations of the fossil. In this way, they can analyze features like bite forces, walking posture and speed, and even physiology. We can even go the extra step and build robots to test their results!

Ichnofossils

Ichnofossils are traces left behind by animal behavior. These come in many forms, which can be classified using the Seilacherian System.

Probably the most famous ichnofossils are things like footprints and burrows left behind by animals moving through sediment. Some interesting examples include footprints from herds of sauropods, an ornithopod family, and some that showed how pterosaurs walked. There are even trackways that have been interpreted as evidence of display behavior.

Dinosaur_Tracks_(14176736955)
A dinosaur trackway from the Jurassic Moenave Formation in Arizona. Image by the U.S. Geological Survey from Flickr.

Trackways not only tell us about where an animal walked, they can also be used to determine its speed and posture.

Other forms of ichnofossils include feeding traces, which can be evidence of attacks from predators, competition, and even cannabilism, and coprolites, which can tell us about diet and digestion.

Ethofossils

In extremely rare cases, we can find fossils of animals preserved in the middle of doing something, or shortly afterward. These are sometimes called ethofossils, fossilized behavior.

There are lots of great examples:

Feeding Behavior and Stomach Content
Snake preserved while possibly hunting baby dinosaurs
Large amphibian choking on a smaller member of its species
Fish that swallowed a fish a bit too large for them to handle
A shark that ate and amphibian that had eaten a fish

Social Behavior
Social marsupial cousins
A juvenile group of ornithomimid dinosaurs
– Potential pack hunting in Deinonychus, though this is disputed

Parental Care
The caring Oviraptor guarding its eggs
Maiasaura, the “good mother reptile”
A traveling family of dinosaurs
A dinosaur parent with young in a burrow

Probably the most famous behavior fossil is “The Fighting Dinosaurs” of Mongolia, which preserves the skeletons of Velociraptor mongoliensis and Protoceratops andrewsi apparently in the middle of a fight. The skeletons are intertwined with the Velociraptor grabbing the head and kicking at the neck of the Protoceratops, while the Protoceratops bites the Velociraptor‘s right arm.  Only one other fossil has ever come close to preserving such a dynamic moment in fossil history, the “Dueling Dinosaurs” of the Hell Creek Formation, but unfortunately this specimen remains in private storage so has yet to be analysed.

Velociraptor_v._Protoceratops
An artist’s reconstruction of the fight that occurred between these two dinosaurs shows how the fossils were interlocked before being suddenly buried. Image by Raul Martin from Wikimedia Commons.

And more!

If you’d like to look into more sources about fossil behavior take a look at these:

Bird behaviour, the ‘deep time’ perspective
How do we know what we know about dinosaur behaviour?
Fossil dinosaur slept like a bird
Embryos of an Early Jurassic Prosauropod Dinosaur and Their Evolutionary Significance
Tyrannosaurus was not a fast runner
Actually, You Could Have Outrun a T. rex
Tyrannosaurus rex ate meat but also accidentally planted fruit

Social Behaviour in Dinosaurs – with David Hone:

 

As always, we invite you to follow us on Twitter or Facebook, consider supporting us on Patreon to get bonus recordings and other goodies, and check out our new store on Zazzle!

Comments, questions, likes, reviews, etc. are always appreciated!
Email: commondescentpodcast@gmail.com

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s